I love so much of this game, but my favorite things was probably when I picked Donald for the Christmas spell."Hi..."
It's so simple and sweet. It shouldn't have made my heart skip, but it did. I ended up squeeing and giggling from that...
I also really liked:
Ellen Path: The Conspiracy
, and freaking out about the romanctic valintine
All of Virginia's path
That one scene with Pastel
The cookie after the first exam
Detention after the monster exam (Suki Power!
Failing studying late in the game (Seek Hugs; Hug Isobel or Blow Off Steam; Scream Wildly in the main courtyard
Any romantic scene with Grabiner (I also kind of liked the scene when he got really pissed off at us for "telling everyone"
Donald Path: When he pranks you in the dungeons
Giving Steve Mr. Hoppity (and getting Mr. Hoppity back if you dance with Steve at the ball
The valentine from Mr. Hoppity
Potsdam... all of Potsdam
Is "the entire game was my favorite moment" an acceptable answer?